Skip Navigation
Analysis

The Links Between Mass Incarceration and Poverty

Robin Hood CEO Wes Moore looks at some of the harms created by the criminal legal system, as well as potential solutions.

  • Wes Moore
March 1, 2021
A close-up shot of the door of a prison cell.
Michael Macor/Getty

This was origin­ally published as the fore­word to the Bren­nan Center report “Poverty and Mass Incar­cer­a­tion in New York: An Agenda for Change.”

The past year has been a reck­on­ing. As a nation, we were finally forced to confront the real­ity and inter­con­nec­ted­ness of racism, inequal­ity, and injustice, which have permeated our insti­tu­tions and systems for centur­ies. When the protests that began in Minneapolis made their way to New York, we marched not just for George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Eric Garner, or Fred­die Gray but for all the lives that have been stolen and deval­ued by the very systems that are meant to uphold and preserve justice.

Recov­ery — of our health, our economy, and the moral fabric of our soci­ety — will take a nation­wide effort in which we all must parti­cip­ate, and that means address­ing the broken systems and inequit­ies in our own communit­ies. In New York, we have a long road ahead of us.

Despite efforts to shrink it, New York’s prison infra­struc­ture is one of the largest in the coun­try. Today, more than 40,000 New York­ers are behind bars and another 337,000 have spent time in prison at some point in their lives; three-quar­ters of them are people of color. As the recent Bren­nan Center report Convic­tion, Impris­on­ment, and Lost Earn­ings: How Involve­ment with the Crim­inal Justice System Deep­ens Inequal­ity shows, this creates enorm­ous, last­ing consequences for impacted indi­vidu­als, famil­ies, and communit­ies. Time spent in prison can reduce a person’s life­time earn­ing poten­tial by half a million dollars. In New York State alone, impris­on­ment trans­lates to nearly $2 billion annu­ally in reduced earn­ings, over­whelm­ingly extrac­ted from communit­ies of color, the very communit­ies Robin Hood serves.

Between poli­cing, jails, pris­ons, proba­tion, and parole, New York State, its counties, and its local­it­ies spent $18.2 billion on the carceral system in 2019, accord­ing to a new report by the Center for Community Altern­at­ives. By contrast, New York spent just $6.2 billion that year on mental health services, public health, youth programs and services, recre­ation, and elder services.

This is no acci­dent or aber­ra­tion. Budgets are not impar­tial or apolit­ical docu­ments; they are reflec­tions of who and what we value as a soci­ety. Ours show us that for gener­a­tions, New York’s crim­inal justice system has inten­tion­ally and system­at­ic­ally blocked low-income communit­ies of color from real­iz­ing economic oppor­tun­ity and exer­cising their human poten­tial, and instead made poverty and impris­on­ment endemic to them.

But policies and budgets can change. Last year, New York passed import­ant reforms related to discov­ery, bail, and trial conduct, and our over­all prison popu­la­tion contin­ues to drop year over year. Follow­ing the lead of states includ­ing Louisi­ana, Missouri, and South Caro­lina, New York legis­lat­ors and advoc­ates have advanced a new set of prior­it­ies. The Less Is More Act, for example, would prevent thou­sands of New York­ers from being rein­car­cer­ated for tech­nical parole viol­a­tions like being late for curfew, fail­ing a drug test, or miss­ing appoint­ments with a parole officer.

The report that follows explores many poten­tial reforms that would decrease the flow of people into the system, reduce overly punit­ive penal­ties, and provide greater support to those who are formerly incar­cer­ated. We must not let our momentum or determ­in­a­tion waver. While we cannot erase the harms done to gener­a­tions disen­fran­chised by our crim­inal justice system, we can change how our soci­ety values the lives of those who have passed through it. We can create budgets that prior­it­ize our schools over our pris­ons, and we can invest in our communit­ies instead of surveilling them.

That would be the kind of last­ing, mean­ing­ful change that millions took to the streets to secure in the name of justice for lives taken far too soon.
 

Wes Moore is the chief exec­ut­ive officer of Robin Hood.