Skip Navigation

Buying Time 2010: West Virginia

This page features West Virginia judicial ads of 2010.

Published: September 19, 2010

West Virginia experienced a number of newsworthy judicial elections over the last decade.  In 2004, a group called “And for the Sake of the Kids” spent more than $3 million to defeat an incumbent Justice, Warren McGraw, and to elect his challenger, Brent D. Benjamin.  More than $2 million of the money raised by And for the Sake of the Kids was contributed by a single coal executive — Don Blankenship, the CEO of Massey Energy.  When Justice Benjamin later refused to recuse himself from a case in which Massey was appealing a $50 million verdict, the case — Caperton v. Massey — went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, which ordered Justice Benjamin disqualified.  In a 2008 election, then-Chief Justice Elliott Maynard was ousted after pictures surfaced of him vacationing with Blankenship in the South of France.

In 2010, one Justice on West Virginia’s Supreme Court of Appeals was up for re-election.  Justice Thomas McHugh, a Democrat, faced off against Republican challenger John Yoder on November’s ballot.  McHugh retained his seat.

Click here to return to the Buying Time — 2010 Homepage


October 20, 2010 – We Agree

Stream Video QT | Download Storyboard

An ad by Justice McHugh saying he is fair and respected. 

October 5, 2010 – Know Tom

Stream Video QTDownload Storyboard

Voters know and respect Justice McHugh.

October 5, 2010 – Patient-Physician

Stream Video QTDownload Storyboard

Justice McHugh has worked to preserve the patient-physician relationship in West Virginia

September 26, 2010 – Service

Stream Video QTDownload Storyboard

Thomas McHugh asks voters to allow him to continue to serve on the Supreme Court of Appeals.


Tony Mauro, West Virginia Justice Reverses Self, Recuses In Malpractice Case, The Blog of Legal Times, September 27, 2010.

Tony Mauro, New Recusal Controversy in West Virginia High Court, The Blog of Legal Times, September 24, 2010.